And one day I’d like another sky.


In the 26 years, 1 month, and 7 days that I’ve been alive, the universe has afforded me one Tinder date. Just one. And that’s probably due to the amount of mental energy it takes to give yourself the sort of pep talk before a first date that looks like this: “Okay, he has sent me a selfie. I’ve heard his voice. There is a person who exists beyond the screen. I will not be Catfished. I will not be murdered. We will meet in a public place. And we can just lie to people and say we met in Aisle 7 if this all works out. Okay… we’re doing this. We’re really doing this.”

Alas, after that one date, the Gods of Tinder never showed their faces to me again. And I’ve retired from the game. And then un-retired. And then re-retired again.

As a sidenote to those who don’t know the mystery that is Tinder, it’s a dating application. It’s like Pandora for people— you get to swipe through a collection of faces and accept the people you are attracted to and decline the ones who don’t suit your fancy. And if you and the other person are in agreement with swiping “YES,” you’re brought into an exclusive conversation. Your own little chatroom. The world is your oyster after that, baby. 

So this all sounds really shallow when I type it out. I’m seeing that now. And while I used to think it was an ankle-deep app for people who only want to hook up at 3a.m. and need a mile radius to know how feasible the chances of that happening really is, it seems to have shifted into a more legitimate avenue to meet people. A lot of my friends are going on Tinder dates. We’ve had girls’ nights where Tinder stories seem to steer the conversation. Someone in my office is actually engaged because of the glorious power of swiping right (and she’s too awesome to sum up into words already and now she has a pretty awesome love story, all thanks to Tinder). 

And this is all really a bunch of breaking-the-ice word vomit just so I can reach a point where I am comfortable enough to just say it: I’m single. Yup. That’s me. I’m solo. I eat alone. And I’ve wondered why it’s so hard to talk about that. I wonder why I’m met with glares and uneven faces when the word “Tinder” gets said in a group.  I wonder why I often feel lame, as if admitting defeat, when I tell someone I am single— as if I am genuinely sorry to announce that I haven’t met someone yet. And I’m trying to be okay with admitting that I sometimes feel like I’m floundering in a culture that seems to associate “singleness” with missing pieces. 

I want to seem like a cool single girl.

If there is even such a thing, if people even find themselves saying things like, “She’s a cool single girl,” then I want to be that. 

And that’s just because I spent a long time doing this whole “single” thing wrong. Trust me, I used to have my days of acting like the President of the Single Girl Gauntlet. I’ve whined with the bunches of them. I’ve asked the same questions: Do guys even call anymore? Is chivalry dead? What happened to running into someone in an airport? Do I really have to go online? 

The questions— they got me nowhere. The whining— it got me ten steps in the opposite direction of the person I knew I was capable of being. I was just choosing daily to stay mad at a world that made me feel like I was missing pieces when I was the one saying it the loudest, “You are missing pieces. You aren’t enough.” 

The problem wasn’t guys. The problem wasn’t the digital age. The problem wasn’t the rose ceremonies being denied to me. It was me. I was the problem. I was the one hunting down completion through another person. I wanted someone to give me a world I could go only go out there and grab on my own. 

That seems to be the wicked spell I’ve seen get cast upon the ones of us who have fallen in love before: it becomes really hard to convince yourself that another person didn’t complete you.  You get comfortable with the phone calls. You get comfortable with the silly messages that only you get to read. You get comfortable with the passenger seat being full. And your hand being held. And your darker parts being known. And your thirst being quenched, even if only for a little while. And when it is gone— you think you need it all over again. And it’s easy to get bitter when you treat your want like a need. 

But what I really needed? I needed to see all the ways I was standing in my own way before I ever welcomed someone else into that equation, thinking they could solve it for me. 

The story of how I got to that exact point is for another day but I know I packed a full suitcase for the girl I used to be and I sent her off with a one-way ticket in her hand. But I can still imagine what it would be like to sit across the table from that girl I used to be— both of us pursing lattes, cradled by fingers baring too much chipped polish— and tell her what I know now: Time gets wasted when you’re not content. And you not seeing the blessings for this moment is a disservice to all the people who don’t get a free life like yours. And if you ever hope to convince someone else they are complete and whole and good as they are— if a shred of you has ever wanted to tell someone that— then you should really stop acting like you’re the puzzle with too many pieces of the sky gone missing. You should stop thinking anyone but yourself can change that insecure part of you. A guy won’t change it. A Tinder swipe won’t cure the wound. You looking for something to plug the hole won’t do it. Humans are just humans, they aren’t lifeboats. They aren’t bandaids. They aren’t completion. 

A mentor of mine who worked at my college met someone unexpectedly during the summer of my junior year and decided not to return to our small campus come the fall. She’d always been there everyday. And then she suddenly wasn’t.

She sent an email. She gave up her job. She deserved the world, really. I emailed her back and told her that.

She wrote back to tell me this: you’ll find that the most astounding love will meet you when you are complete. When you can stand before yourself— in a mirror, in the car, or wherever you do all that internal talking— and say, “I am okay alone. I am cool on my own. I am legitimate. They should write rap anthems about me. Or at least play “Ridin’ Solo” when I walk into a room. I’m single and that doesn’t mean I’m not complete.”

And she told me it would be an even better love when the person who chooses you is complete too. And sees your completeness. And you can both sit there with your hands in the spaces of one another and recognize: there is no completing this time around. There is adding on. There is complimenting one another. But there is no completing because you’re not any missing pieces. 

When I read those words of hers, it made me think back to a childhood packed full with Puzzle Nights. That was a thing (that’s why I capitalized it). A legitimate thing. And just to further complicate the lives of anyone who sat down at our kitchen table for the traditional night of puzzles and hot cocoa, my brothers and I would pour out the contents of two puzzles– similar in theme– onto the table. We were still babies with something to prove. Instead of 500 pieces, there’d suddenly be 1,000. And if you’ve ever tried to assemble two puzzles at once, you draw a lot of conclusions quickly: there’s a lot of sky. There’s a lot of clouds. There’s a lot of random inanimate objects that seem to stretch in to the abyss of infinity. 

But I think that’s what happens when you share a life with someone— you realize it’s two puzzles. No matter how “one” you become, there are still two puzzles scattered on the table. Two skies. Two sets of clouds. Two very different landscapes. 

If you’re single, I think it’s probably better to resolve and say: Okay, I have my own pieces right now. Only mine. And one day I’d like another sky. So I will do my best to figure out the pieces I am holding while there is still just one puzzle to solve. 

The post should have ended right with that last line.

It would have been really poetic and cool. But I can suspect several emails coming my way after I click publish on this piece, asking me the question I haven’t answered for you yet: 

How did that one Tinder date go? 

Well, in the history of dates I’ve gone on, it was a pretty good one. It scores pretty high. 

We met halfway in as small, unheard-of town at the only restaurant we could find in the hour of distance between us that didn’t look like KFC and the Olive Garden had a baby together. It was a small pizza joint. The conversation was good. We both admitted to being fearful that Nev from Catfish might show up for the date in the place of one another. He wore Vans. We drove around the other small towns that encased that one small town. We blasted “White Houses” by Vanessa Carlton. I used his glove compartment as a drum set.

He was moving away, and I was restless with my own location on a map, so we only had one date. But I was complete that night. And I like to think he was complete. And we asked for nothing more of one another than summer air and a conversation that left us saying, as we went in our separate directions: keep getting out there in the world and giving it everything you have. I don’t know you all that well but I have a hunch you’ll do just fine. 

26 thoughts on “And one day I’d like another sky.

  1. As a young married woman, I’d like to offer this thought: if we’ve got our own puzzle pieces to figure out, don’t expect to have a complete puzzle before allowing yourself love. Don’t make it an ultimatum. Don’t get so wrapped up in figuring out your puzzle and being the version of yourself you want to be before saying yes to something beautiful. Don’t read me wrong… I’m not saying to say yes to anything. Or that you shouldn’t want the best version of yourself… the you that you are in your core. I’m just afraid that we tend to set really high expectations that we’ll either never meet, or we’ll meet in time… more time than we usually allow. “Complete” can mean a thousand different things to all of us. A husband, or a wife, isn’t designed to complete you… but my husband has helped me travel my journey all the more beautifully. He’s helped me with my puzzle, if that’s the metaphor we’re using. I wasn’t the best version of myself before I got married. I didn’t have it all figured out and a lot of my puzzle pieces were still fuzzy. And that’s okay. I think we’re complete in Christ… and that’s not a puzzle. That’s just plain truth. And the good people in our lives help us see that. They draw out the love, the light, the living and breathing Holy Spirit in us. And these things help us see the puzzle pieces of our life from truth, and in light. I just don’t think it’s our job to complete… ourselves or our wives and husbands. Just sharing a thought that came up as I was reading. Much love from California!

  2. You never cease to rock my little world with your witty words and to the point metaphors. I sat at my computer with watered eyes on this one. You are a lighthouse. thank you

  3. Hannah Freaking Brencher –

    YOU ARE A BALLER! You say you are no expert, but that is simply not true. Your ability to touch me through a screen is insane, and beautiful! I LOVE THIS POST! I am single and have been my whole life…28 years is a long time 😉 I haven’t really felt like something was missing, but that I was missing out. Missing out on the handholding and the kissing and the watching a movie on a rainy day moments. But now I see that I am completing my puzzle – making it whole so that someday when God brings me my person (or my lobster – FRIENDS FOR LIFE!) we will be two complete puzzles that can sit next to each other and compliment each other. Thank you for writing this Hannah.

    SO MUCH LOVE, Nicole

    P.S. You are a cool single girl – a badass single girl – a single girl who is changing the world. I can’t wait to see the man that gets to have you, he is gonna be one lucky dude!

  4. As a 50-yr. old woman, what you hit on is probably THE most common reason I’ve seen for divorce: Two incomplete people hook up looking for completion in the other. That always fails so instead of realizing their happiness has to come from within themselves, they blame the other, walk out, and go looking for more puzzle pieces. Thankfully, some of us figure out “wherever you go, there you are” and hang tough, seeking something inside rather than out. By grace alone my husband and I have walked 27 years together, still two broken, incomplete people who understand NO ONE else will ever be able to complete us.

    GREAT post, and so important! God bless you on your journey, Hannah.

  5. YES. YES. YES! Thank you so much for sharing! This is exactly what I needed to be reminded of right now. Too often this is just head knowledge for me, I’m working on getting it to my heart.

  6. Hey HB! This is really a great and inspiring post.

    I always believed that you cannot give what you don’t have. We must start to value and love ourselves more and just enjoy the single life for now. In the right time that person will come our way and sometimes unexpected.

    Two broken people cannot be together, it will never work. For a couple to be called as “One” both person MUST BE WHOLE FIRST. I also agree that only us can fill up the missing pieces in our lives. We will never receive that missing piece from the other person because they are not living our lives. We are the one responsible for whatever needed to fix or to fill up in our lives.

    As a single woman I enjoy the beauty of single life. And I always believe that in God’s time, whoever the man in my future.. I know one day we will cross our path. I’m pretty excited to meet him. 🙂

    Thanks for sharing this! Be blessed!

    – Gen 😉

  7. YES! here’s to each of us completing our own puzzle and also realizing we ARE complete without another human. Thank you so much Hannah for another beautiful post which came at a time I needed this reminder. Most of the time I am A-OK being single, I am happy, grateful, relatively well adjusted, it is society that gets to me. ‘How can YOU be single at your age?” or “Don’t you miss being in a relationship?” This is what sometimes wears me down. the Having to explain, “actually I Enjoy being Single. I enjoy picking up and traveling and leaving where/ when I please. If you have any gems to say to others who are Forcing the whole, “Are you Sure you’re happy single?” or “Really, you feel complete alone?!” as if it’s some disease to choose to be single. Thanks. HUG

  8. Thank you, thank you, thank you, Hannah!
    This post couldn’t have come at a better time.
    I don’t want to miss out on life because I’m too busy waiting for “the one” to complete me…I’ve been doing a pretty good job of being content with my singleness but it’s all too easy to fall into the “You complete me” trap. Thanks for the kick in the butt. I needed that 🙂

  9. Last night, as I sat in the semi-dark of my bedroom, sobbing my heart out because I didn’t know what else to do, I realized that my puzzle is incomplete. Except I didn’t know it was a puzzle until I read your post. So, thank you.

  10. Just when I was about to start feeling bad again about my single life. It can be so hard but sometimes such a relief to be “riding solo”. I’ve got to keep working on my puzzle. Thanks!

  11. So I’m going to a very important job interview today and if you would pray for me that be spectacular. And super duper appreciated. THANK YOU!!!!!!

  12. It’s like you somehow got into my head and knew what I needed to hear right now. When that passenger seat becomes empty and you find yourself with empty drawers and hangers it’s so easy to feel like you need to fill them back up again and that there’s something wrong with you if they stay unoccupied for too long.

    I will do my best to always remind myself that I am not broken or missing pieces because I’m not part of a matched set. I am my own complete puzzle.

  13. І comment when I like a article ߋn a site or I have sߋmething tto valuable too contribute to the discussion.
    It is a result of the sincerness displayed iin the post I looked at.
    And aftter thіs article And one day Id like another sky.
    | Hannah Brencher. I was actually excited enough to drop a comment :
    -) I ddo have 2 questions foг you if you don’t mind.
    Is it simply me or do a feѡ of the сomments appear like they are left
    by brain deaԀ visitorѕ? 😛 Аnd, if you aree posting on other social sites, I’d like
    to follow everytthing new you hace tto post. Could you list the complete urls of all ypuг sҺaredd pzges like youг
    twitter feed, Faceboοk page or linkedin profile?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s